Comments on: Knowledge vs. Information Which is it?

By: Shockerz

Shockerz — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 13:51:37 +0000

This is certainly insightful on what I’m searching for. So, there are a difference between knowledge and information.

By: Jack Pierce

Jack Pierce — Mon, 14 Dec 2009 01:28:03 +0000

Three points…

1) You’re right…new behaviors often rest on knowledge, but knowledge alone is never enough.

2) It’s no excuse that most designers don’t have the skill to design immersive simulations and serious games…skills can be learned.

3) Designing sims and games doesn’t have to be that expensive, especially when you get rid of all the other stuff that doesn’t need to be there.

Oh…and holodecks would be good! Maybe that’s the next blog post!

By: Brother Andrew

Brother Andrew — Sun, 13 Dec 2009 07:14:15 +0000

Good point Jack. However I do think that in the end we’re still hoping that our learner walks away from our course with knowledge that is stuck in their brain. I don’t think that focusing on the word “knowledge” is off point at all.
I like your idea about how to better engrain knowledge into our learners. Your thoughts about immersing them in real-life is great. All training should be like that. The problem is many designers don’t have those skills, don’t realize they need to, and/or can’t pay for it.
Maybe some day we’ll all jut train in holodecks like in Star Trek.

By: Jack Pierce

Jack Pierce — Sat, 12 Dec 2009 02:00:10 +0000

I appreciate the considerations of this post, but respectfully, I think you are focused on the wrong terms.

e-Learning design should provide learners with exploration, practice, failure and feedback…in other words, learning by doing…in order to change behaviors and build new competencies. Success requires going way beyond simple information and knowledge.

For more thought on this I invite your comments on the following blog post: e-Learning For Practice And Competency http://bit.ly/6mTHqq

By: Matt Moore

Matt Moore — Wed, 09 Dec 2009 21:33:54 +0000

I believe the knowledge vs information distinction throws down a radical challenge to instructional designers. We have to consider the whole learning environment in which our learners operate – of which a specific course might only be a small component (this for me is what constructivism ultimately leads to).

Design organisations such as IDEO can show us a lot about how to do that – as can F2F & virtual facilitators – and the more adventurous knowledge managers (i.e. people interested in more than databases).

By: L.M. Puhr

L.M. Puhr — Wed, 09 Dec 2009 17:56:07 +0000

Consider information as the mosaic tiles of knowledge; information must be manipulated, applied, and “glued in place” in one’s mind to build the knowledge. What do the disperate pieces of information add to an individual’s knowledge base? It is true that we are exposed to more information than ever, but we need to take it to that next level to really determine level of knowledge. Constructivist learning-possibly?

By: J-M. Guillemette

J-M. Guillemette — Wed, 09 Dec 2009 13:42:31 +0000

There is definitely a difference between information and knowledge, although it’s become generalized practice to substitute the two words at will. In essence, information is the input that helps create knowledge, obtained equally from the senses as from what we create. While information may be considered essential for knowledge, being exposed to information does not de facto guarantee that knowledge will result. That requires brain processing to extract meaning from information. Being exposed to greater amounts of information than ever does not de facto make us better problem solvers: it simply means we have greater opportunities to find what we need to learn how to solve problems. Finally, knowledge is something that is created in individual minds. Sharing or transfering knowledge is therefore more a metaphore to distinguish between what someone has thought about before sharing, from handling unprocessed information. It does not equate taking what is in someone’s mind and integrally “installing” it in someone else’s mind. We’re still not that good yet!

By: Ove

Ove — Wed, 09 Dec 2009 09:24:35 +0000

“Where is the wisdom we have lost in knowledge? Where the knowledge we have lost in information?”

T.S. Elliot

By: From data processing to knowledge sharing, and beyond - MeetVirtual

From data processing to knowledge sharing, and beyond - MeetVirtual — Wed, 09 Dec 2009 06:02:35 +0000

[...] interesting blog Knowledge vs. Informationâ€¦Which is it? reminded me on this, to take a look at e-learning; or more precisely learning [...]

By: Vinod Varma

Vinod Varma — Wed, 09 Dec 2009 03:55:50 +0000

At times, it is good to step back and take a look at what we are doing. It helps us do our job better. I like this post from that perspective

To me, learning is moving from known to known, having to work with a lot of data to wisdom where I can make informed decisions.

We live in a world where i) huge amount of data is being created and processed every minute, ii) amount of information we require to consume and process to make decision to stay effective and competitive, both in personal life and business is huge and is increasing, iii) great deal of effort goes into creation of data and processing of information rather than presenting for a purpose

I believe privilege and responsibility of Instructional designers, as you have rightly pointed out, to â€œchunkâ€ and organize information into a format that enables the transfer of knowledge is very critical